Pollinator Action Case Studies


The Red Hook Case Study

Landscapes Designed and Installed

The Red Hook site is an agricultural field owned by Bard College, formerly part of the 380-acre Montgomery Place estate. The 14-acre site is adjacent to (and widely visible from) Route 9G north of the Montgomery Place Orchards farm stand. A National Historic Landmark, Montgomery Place was owned by members of the Livingston family from 1802 until the 1980s. The site slopes downward and westward toward the Hudson River. From the hilltop, there are long western views of the Hudson River and Catskills.

The field was most likely an orchard during the early 20th century; it was later used for hay, then used to grow conventionally managed corn under Bard’s ownership from 2016-2023. After decades of conventional agriculture it offered little to no ecological value or native plant presence, presenting an excellent opportunity for restoration. 

The pilot project was overseen by Bard staff, including the Director of Horticulture and Sustainability Coordinator, with input from interested Bard students. As one low-lying section of the field had consistently wet soil, two separate meadow seed mixes were prepared; one for the 1-acre wet area, and one for the remaining 12 acres, which had average (mesic) soil. The major design constraint for the project was the field’s lack of watering capacity; tough plant species that wouldn’t need watering were used in hedgerows designed for the drier areas. 


  1. Meadows and Hedgerows for Wet and Dry Soil

Site area (overall): 13 acres

Soil: Clay loam; organic matter depleted; rocky, some exposed bedrock (ledge)

Sun exposure: Full

Site history: Agricultural: conventionally managed corn, hay, and former orchard crops.

Existing vegetation: Standing dead cornstalks; mix of non-native and invasive weeds including mugwort (Artemisia vulgaris), chickweed (Stellaria media) and reed canary grass (Phalaris arundinacea). Rocky hilltop was overrun with woody and vining invasives such as Oriental bittersweet (Celastrus orbiculatus) and Japanese honeysuckle (Lonicera japonica).

Site preparation: To prepare both the seeded meadow and woody hedgerow sites, the entire field was sprayed with herbicide three times, in April, June and August. 3-5 weeks elapsed between sprays. Glyphosate and 2,4-D were used, separately or in combination at the discretion of the applicator, a local farmer. NOTE: Herbicide was recommended by the project designer due to the widespread presence of rhizomatous invasive species such as mugwort and reed canary grass. The site had also received aggressive annual herbicide treatment throughout the prior decade.

Meadow area viewed from above, looking west to the Hudson River. Photo: Adam T. Deen

Timeline

April May June July August September October
First herbicide treatment 4/26 Second herbicide treatment 6/20 Plant and seed sourcing research and order placement Third herbicide treatment 8/24 Plants delivered and staged onsite Hedgerows planted 10/9; meadows seeded 10/25

Because many of this project’s activities apply to the entire site - both meadows and hedgerows - the timeline is presented for the site as a whole.

Seeded Meadow Installation

Site area: Twelve acres of dry meadow; 1 acre of wet meadow

Site Prep: Herbicide; see above

Planting Method: Native seed drilling

Meadow Seed Mixes: Adapted versions of the Sunny Dry Mix and Sunny Moist Mix were used. View our recommended meadow mixes.

Cover Crop: Winter wheat at 100 lb/acre, seeded simultaneously with meadow mix on 10/26

Initial Site Conditions

Site Preparation with Herbicide Treatment

Drill Seeding the Meadows

Budget

Item Cost Source
Herbicide application (3 treatments) $3,378.00 Herbicide application was used to prepare the field. Cost included in meadow budget above.
Meadow seed mix + shipping $18,334.94 Prairie Moon Nursery
Seed drilling $4,762.00 Monarch Vegetation Services, Inc.
Winter wheat cover crop (1200 lb) $394.00 Kukon Brothers
TOTAL $26,868.94 Total cost per acre: $2,066.84

Design modifications: A few species were omitted from the mix due to sourcing difficulty


2. Woody Hedgerows and Hilltop Planting

Site area: 6,150 square feet

Elements: Three 100’ x 12’ hedgerows (two for dry soil and one for moist soil); one 50’ x 75’ woody planting on a rocky, windswept hilltop. All plantings are within the larger seeded meadow area.

Site Prep: Herbicide; see above

Planting Preparation: Container plants were laid out onsite the day before planting.

Planting: Holes were dug using a gas-powered handheld auger and shovels. 

Deer Protection: Deer-attractive trees and shrubs were caged, individually or in small groups. Perennials were not caged but were sprayed with deer repellent spray on planting day.

Project Labor: Bard Horticulture staff and students completed planting and fencing. Each 100’ hedgerow took ~8 hours for 2 people to plant, using mainly gas-powered augers for digging

Hedgerow Layout and Planting

Protecting Hedgerows from Deer Browse

Budget

Item Cost Source/Notes
Site Preparation see note Herbicide application was used to prepare the field. Cost included in meadow budget above.
Plants $9,713.04 Deep Roots Direct; North Creek Nursery; One Nature
Deer protection cages: fencing and post materials $1,541.40 Home Depot
Planting labor $0.00 Provided by Bard
TOTAL $11,254.44 Total cost per square foot: $0.41

Design modifications: A few species were substituted by nurseries due to sourcing difficulties. Hilltop planting location was shifted slightly due to discovery of near-surface bedrock in planned planting location.

Site Managers’ Top Takeaways

Site Preparation: We found that the three herbicide treatments didn’t kill the weeds as effectively as we’d hoped; we were told to expect 3-4 sprays, so it’s possible the field needed an additional treatment for maximum effectiveness. It was somewhat difficult to coordinate with the farm contractor, and we weren’t able to prioritize timing with weather and weed regrowth conditions as much as we would have liked. 

For future projects we’ll consider repeated tilling; in areas where that’s not an option, we’d like to set aside both a larger budget and a longer time horizon for site preparation. We plan to explore treatments like controlled burning (repeated over several years), organic herbicides, and perhaps Foamstream™, a patented technology that uses boiling water to kill existing vegetation but isn’t yet available in our area. 

Plant Sourcing: Our usual wholesale nursery could only provide about half the hedgerow and hilltop plants, so we found two more nurseries to work with. Once we took the initial step of branching out from our usual source, we were actually surprised at the number of species available locally, although we still see a huge need for more nursery propagation of these pollinator plants! We were also pleased that we could find “restoration size” plants for most of the species, which are smaller and less expensive than “landscape size”. 

Seed Sourcing: We had a smooth experience working with Prairie Moon. A few species were unavailable, so Prairie Moon removed them from the mix. This decreased the overall seeding rate slightly, so for future projects we’d be sure to request that the quantities of other species are increased to fill any sourcing-related gaps. 

Compared to past meadows we’ve seeded, the recommended mix had a much larger number of species, in order to support the project’s full list of at-risk pollinators. This diversity, and the rarity of some species, made it very expensive. Newcomers to large-scale meadow installation might consider starting with a slightly less diverse mix that includes some more common species known for their reliable germination - a seed company like Prairie Moon can advise on this.

Seeding the Meadows: When the bag of meadow seed arrived, we were shocked at its tiny size - it was hard to believe that amount could really cover 13 acres! We’re glad we went with a native seed drill, and Monarch Vegetation Services was easy to work with. Since we seeded the cover crop at the same time in late October, we were concerned the wheat might not germinate; but it sprouted and grew about 2” before the first hard freeze. 

Planting the Hedgerows and Hilltop: We had no way to water after planting, so we timed the planting for the day before a predicted rain event - but the rain didn’t come for ten days. We’re glad we planted in the fall, as plants were already entering dormancy and temperatures were cool; ten days without rain after planting in spring or summer would have been much worse. 

We had to make a few changes to the location and layout of each planting based on soil, rock, and slope conditions of the field. The hilltop in particular had been overgrown with invasive plants for most of the summer. When these were removed, we found that the hilltop was basically a pile of boulders, not suitable for planting - so we shifted the planting and path area down the slope. When planting according to a design drawing, it’s important to stay flexible and adapt to real-world conditions. 

Deer protection: Since the field was previously used to grow corn, the local deer are used to spending time in it; we expected deer browse on our plantings. We protected trees and shrubs in the hedgerows with wire cages, which will need to be hand-weeded. Still, we noticed deer browse on the un-fenced perennial plants within a week after planting. For future projects like this, we might consider fencing the entire hedgerow - this would protect perennials as well as woody plants and allow easier weeding within the larger fenced area.